While "pig butchering" may sound like a rural pastime, it’s a chilling substitute for one of the most deceitful forms of financial crime today. The term "Pig Butchering" is a translation from the Chinese term 'shu zhu pan,' found by investigators to be used by Asian scammers when referring to their victims coldly, which can also be translated as “killing pig plate”. Pig butchering scams leverage social engineering to devastating effect.
These scams, driven by organized crime networks and globalized by digital currency, are not only a financial epidemic but a human tragedy. Individuals, often coerced or trafficked, are forced to work within these scam operations, deceiving victims while trapped themselves. Pig butchering scams expose vulnerabilities in jurisdictional collaboration between international law enforcement and exploit the anonymity of cryptocurrency, thriving in regions where oversight is scant.
The Anatomy of Pig Butchering Scams
Pig butchering scams prey on trust and exploit digital anonymity, often starting with scammers posing as romantic or business interests to lure unsuspecting targets. Over weeks or months, they gain their victims’ confidence and coax them into fraudulent investments, usually in cryptocurrency. These schemes create the illusion of profitability, showing false returns to encourage larger investments. Eventually, when the victim attempts to withdraw their funds, they find the entire platform has vanished—along with their savings.
FBI reported more than 69,000 complaints related to cryptocurrency fraud, with losses surpassing $5.6 billion during 2023. Although these cases accounted for only 10% of financial fraud complaints, they represented nearly 50% of total reported losses, a testament to the devastating financial impact pig butchering scams can have (1). United states Institute of peace in their May 2024 report titled Transnational Crime in Southeast Asia estimates there are approximately 500,000 scammers operating in Southeast Asia, which signifies the extent of this problem (2).
Human Trafficking and Coercion in Scam Operations
Hidden behind these scams are thousands of trafficked individuals forced into their operation. Soraton Charehkphunpol’s story is a striking example (3). A young Thai man, Soraton responded to a job advertisement promising high wages in Cambodia. Once there, he was trapped in a heavily guarded compound, stripped of his passport and phone, and forced into relentless online fraud under constant surveillance. His days were consumed with posing as a financial advisor or romantic partner, pressured to meet financial quotas and meet targets through any means necessary. After months of intimidation, he was finally rescued with the help of activists, but his experience reflects the extreme exploitation many trafficked individuals endure.
These scam compounds, often in Southeast Asia’s special economic zones, are structured to evade scrutiny. Situated alongside casinos and other businesses, they benefit from limited law enforcement presence, moving locations or altering operations as needed to avoid detection. This insulation allows organized criminal groups to exploit trafficked individuals with impunity.
The Emotional Toll on Victims
For victims, the emotional impact of these scams is often as painful as the financial loss. Dennis Jones, an 82-year-old retiree, became entangled in a pig butchering scam after meeting "Jessie" on Facebook (4). Their months-long friendship led to Jessie convincing him to invest in a supposed cryptocurrency opportunity. Initial small investments seemed to yield impressive returns, which emboldened Dennis to commit more. By the time he attempted to withdraw, his savings were gone, and Jessie disappeared. The isolation, guilt, and betrayal weighed heavily on Dennis, driving him to a tragic end. His story underscores the profound psychological manipulation that often lies at the heart of these scams.
Dennis’s story exemplifies how pig butchering scams skillfully exploit emotional vulnerabilities. By separating victims from their support networks, scammers deepen their psychological grip. Victims, particularly older adults unfamiliar with digital fraud, are often left with overwhelming shame, amplifying the scam’s destructive impact.
Astonishingly, pig butchering scams don’t just target the uninformed; they can trap even financially savvy individuals. Such was the case with a Kansas bank CEO who diverted $47.1 million from his bank and local organizations into a fraudulent cryptocurrency scheme, ultimately leading to the bank's collapse (5). This incident underscores that pig butchering scams can trap even those with financial expertise, exposing a vulnerability that extends well beyond everyday consumers. It reveals the sophisticated tactics scammers employ to deceive even seasoned finance professionals.
How Pig Butchering Scams Operate
Pig butchering scams run on a sophisticated infrastructure of digital deception, relying on fake financial platforms with authentic-looking interfaces and customer service agents. These sites, complete with “financial advisors,” vanish as soon as funds are extracted, making asset recovery nearly impossible. Cryptocurrencies, favored for their anonymity and complexity of laundering techniques available, enable scammers to transfer funds swiftly across borders, creating a web of shell companies and offshore accounts to obscure the stolen money.
Criminals exploit cryptocurrency because its decentralized and borderless nature allows them to transfer funds globally without the need for financial intermediaries, making it easier to evade traditional controls. Transactions occur instantly and are irreversible, which means they cannot be easily intercepted or canceled. One of the only known methods of asset recovery is to leverage blockchain analytics to trace the stolen funds to a compliant chokepoint, like exchanges which adhere to jurisdictional anti-money laundering regulations.
While cryptocurrency transactions are recorded on public blockchains, allowing for some traceability, criminals still find ways to obscure the flow of funds by using exchanges in jurisdictions with lax anti-money laundering regulations. These characteristics make cryptocurrency an appealing vehicle for illicit activities like fraud, theft, and money laundering, despite law enforcement efforts to trace and disrupt these networks (1).
A recent U.S. case revealed just how intricate these pig butchering operations can be, with suspects allegedly moving $80 million through a network of shell companies and bank accounts before converting it to Tether (USDT) (6). Tether, like other stablecoins, allows the preservation of the assets value, pegged to a fiat currency, as opposed to other cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, of which the value is vulnerable to large swings in price due to market volatility.
The scam's scale underscores the degree to which organized crime orchestrates these activities, often using trafficked individuals coerced into high-security compounds to execute scams. Compounds, typically retrofitted casinos, are found in special economic zones in countries like Myanmar, Cambodia, and Laos, where regulation is light, and government officials may be complicit.
In these compounds, trafficked individuals face extreme coercion. Surrounded by high walls, CCTV surveillance, and armed guards, many are effectively prisoners, barred from leaving and punished if they resist or underperform. Facilities are often associated with local elites and protected by government-backed militias, allowing criminal groups to conduct their operations without fear of law enforcement (2).
The Scope of the Problem and Regional Adaptations
Pig butchering scams are no longer confined to Southeast Asia; they have spread into the Middle East and Africa. Conservative estimates put global annual losses from these scams at $75 billion (7). These operations adapt quickly, shifting regions or methods in response to regulatory changes or law enforcement actions. Experts suggest international cooperation, sanctions on syndicate leaders, and accountability for complicit governments and industry participants are essential steps. Furthermore, clandestine communications platforms like Telegram that facilitate these scams require closer monitoring and regulatory action to mitigate their use in fraud.
The Global Response and the Role of Social Media
The transnational scope of pig butchering scams, linked with organized crime and human trafficking, has mobilized governments, law enforcement agencies, and global organizations. Criminal syndicates often move across borders to evade detection, seeking regions with lax regulation or law enforcement oversight. In response, agencies like the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) are collaborating with Southeast Asian governments to share intelligence and target trafficking networks (8). Enforcement efforts include raids on scam compounds, though limited resources and jurisdictional challenges hinder their effectiveness.
Major social media players have also responded to the demands for action. The launch of Tech Against Scams—a partnership of major tech, crypto, and dating companies like Meta, Coinbase, and Match Group—signals an attempt by the industry to address the growing issue of online romance, “pig butchering” and other scams (9). By sharing threat intelligence and resources, these companies aim to identify and remove fraudulent actors more effectively, potentially disrupting fraud networks.
However, the effectiveness of these efforts remains to be proven, especially because several significant industry members, including Binance and Tether, remain outside the initiative. As a result, deeper collaboration between social media companies, financial institutions, and governments remains essential to enhance early detection systems and limit scammers' access to potential victims.
A Legislative Step Forward: The Philippines' Anti-Financial Account Scamming Act
In July of 2024, the Philippines enacted the Anti-Financial Account Scamming Act (AFASA), marking a critical legislative advance in Southeast Asia’s fight against organized cybercrime (10). Beyond penalizing direct perpetrators, AFASA includes safe harbor protections for trafficked individuals forced into scams, ensuring they aren’t criminalized for actions taken under duress. This distinction is particularly important in a region where crime syndicates exploit vulnerable individuals for fraud. AFASA’s severe penalties, including life imprisonment for economic sabotage, aim to deter cybercriminals and reinforce public trust in digital financial systems. Other nations should consider similar legislation and enforcement frameworks to address the multifaceted and transnational nature of these crimes.
Conclusion: Building Awareness and Enhancing Prevention
As pig butchering scams grow in sophistication, the intersection of cyber fraud and human trafficking demands proactive, coordinated action. Public awareness remains a strong defense, especially for high-risk groups like seniors. Recognizing common red flags—unsolicited investment opportunities, unrealistic returns, and urgent demands for funds—can help prevent these crimes. Community awareness and open discussions about digital safety are also crucial in reinforcing protective measures.
Ultimately, combating pig butchering scams requires unified global efforts from governments, industry organizations, and the private sector. As criminals evolve, sustained collaboration, robust oversight, and ongoing public education are essential to reducing the reach and impact of these exploitative schemes.
Meet The Author - Kashif Ghani
Follow Kashif on LinkedIn at: https://www.linkedin.com/in/kashifghani/
Sources:
FBI - 2023 CRYPTOCURRENCY FRAUD REPORT.. https://www.ic3.gov/AnnualReport/Reports/2023_IC3CryptocurrencyReport.pdf
Transnational Crime in Southeast Asia a Growing Threat to Global Peace and Security. (May 2024). US Institute of Peace: https://www.usip.org/sites/default/files/2024-05/ssg_transnational-crime-southeast-asia.pdf
LA Times. “‘I Was a Slave’: Up to 100,000 Held Captive by Chinese Cybercriminals in Cambodia.” November 1, 2022. https://www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2022-11-01/i-was-a-slave-up-to-100-000-held-captive-by-chinese-cyber-criminals-in-cambodia.
CNN: “Killed by a Scam: A Father Took His Life after Losing His Savings to Criminal Gangs in Asia. He’s Not the Only One.” June 17, 2024. https://www.cnn.com/2024/06/17/asia/pig-butchering-scam-southeast-asia-dst-intl-hnk/index.html.
CNBC. “Cryptocurrency ‘Pig Butchering’ Scam Wrecks Kansas Bank, Sends Ex-CEO to Prison for 24 Years.” August 21, 2024. https://www.cnbc.com/2024/08/21/cryptocurrency-shan-hanes-pig-butchering-scam.html.
NBC News. “Four Charged by Feds, Accused of Running an $80 Million ‘Pig Butchering’ Scheme.” NBC News. December 14, 2023. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/four-charged-feds-accused-running-80-million-pig-butchering-scheme-rcna129811.
Bloomberg.com. “Pig-Butchering Crypto Scams Netted More than $75 Billion, New Study Finds.” February 29, 2024. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-02-29/pig-butchering-crypto-scams-netted-more-than-75-billion-new-study-finds?embedded-checkout=true.
UN News: “Southeast Asia: Torture Rooms and Karaoke Bars in Gang-Run ‘Scam Farms.’” July 10, 2024. https://news.un.org/en/story/2024/07/1151886.
Fortune Crypto. “Meta and Coinbase Link up with Match to Fight Pig-Butchering, Romance Scams.” May 21, 2024. https://fortune.com/crypto/2024/05/21/tech-against-scams-coinbase-meta-match
Central Bank of the Philippines (Bangko Sentral Ng Pilipinas) Press Releases and Advisories 2024. Bsp.gov.ph. 2024. https://www.bsp.gov.ph/SitePages/MediaAndResearch/MediaDisp.aspx?ItemId=7179.
Comments